|
by Viviana Santiago, Intern, Domestic Policy
In November 2009, a 27-year-old pregnant mother of four suffering from pulmonary hypertension was admitted to St. Joseph's Catholic Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix, Arizona. This condition has a mortality rate of between 30% and 56% in pregnant women. The pulmonary hypertension and right heart failure from which the woman was suffering led doctors to conclude that unless she aborted her 11-week-old fetus, the probability of death for her and her 11-week fetus was nearly 100%.
As the woman was too weak to be moved to another hospital, Sister Margaret McBride, a long-standing hospital administrator, member of the ethics panel at St. Joseph’s, and liaison to the diocese, authorized the young woman to have the abortion she needed. As a result, the young woman’s life and health were preserved.
This week, upon learning of the abortion, Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted of Phoenix immediately excommunicated Sister Margaret McBride for her role in supporting the abortion. Excommunication is the most serious penalty the church can impose.
For me, this story brings a number of questions to the forefront:
1) Are Catholic hospitals safe for pregnant women? Are they places in which medical decisions will be based on what is best for the woman's health, not on religious dogma? To what code of ethics should these hospitals be held in terms of patient care?
|