Advocates' Blog
Planned Parenthood “sting” as pointless as usual

by Emily Bridges, Director, Public Information Services

The activist group LiveAction, working with anti-abortion activist Lila Rose, is pretty pleased with its series of “stings” on Planned Parenthood. What they "uncover" seems to be that Planned Parenthood provides abortions, which I thought anti-abortion activists were already well aware of, but which always seems shocking to them. 

Today’s noise specifically is around sex-selective abortion. In the recently released Live Action video, a woman visiting a Planned Parenthood clinic tells the counselor that she plans to abort if the fetus is female.  

This operation’s cover had already been blown in April. That’s because, as Amanda Marcotte pointed out, requests for sex-selective abortion are so rare that Planned Parenthood staff immediately knew something was fishy when the actors came to the clinics. 

So: the video is about a theoretical medical procedure that would be highly statistically unlikely in this country. 

Plus, the counselor doesn’t advise anything illegal. 

Thus, having no real whistle to blow, the video uses the fictional scenario to get you to respond emotionally to the idea of sex-selective abortion and to call for it to be outlawed. 

“Surely you care about female babies – surely you don’t CONDONE aborting female babies?” they ask – pressuring us as pro-choice activists to condemn this kind of abortion.

 


Our girls are at risk, “especially in China,” the video is careful to note – preparing the viewer to make assumptions about the race of the woman asking for the abortion: race-baiting being another of the anti-abortion movement’s favorite tricks

And it’s no coincidence: yesterday the video is released; today Congress votes on legislation which would ban abortion based on the sex of a fetus, which threatens doctors with up to five years in prison if they perform such an abortion.  (Read Aimee Thorne-Thomsen's blog on this legislation)

It’s by dividing and conquering – by getting us to judge other women’s abortions – that they chip away at abortion rights, passing restrictions for young people, bans after a certain point in the pregnancy, bans on certain reasons for the abortion. They invite us to distance ourselves from the abortions we personally don’t approve of, and shame us as monsters if we respond by saying we support all women’s right to decide if and when to end a pregnancy. 

But we must always remember that their goal isn’t to prevent sex-selective abortions or 20 week abortions or “frivolous” abortions. It’s to ban all abortions. LiveAction’s videos are a sideshow, but with this week’s legislation and hundreds of bills pending in state legislatures, we can’t afford to just roll our eyes at anti-abortion tactics or keep quiet when the conversation would be unpleasant. We can’t afford to give them any ground at all – we must stand in solidarity with all women and activists and demand the right to safe and legal abortion.
 
AMPLIFYYOUR VOICE.ORG
a youth-driven community working for change
AMBIENTEJOVEN.ORG
Apoyo para Jóvenes GLBTQ
for Spanish-speaking GLBTQ youth
MYSISTAHS.ORG
by and for young women of color
MORNINGAFTERINFO.ORG
information on emergency birth control for South Carolina residents
YOUTHRESOURCE.ORG
by and for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, and questioning youth
2000 M Street NW, Suite 750  |  Washington, DC 20036  |  P: 202.419.3420  |  F: 202.419.1448
COPYRIGHT © 2008 Advocates for Youth. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED  |  Contact Us   |  Donate   |  Terms of Use   |  Search